Goldbelly Reviews, Pricing, Pros, and Cons

Goldbelly Reviews, Pricing, Pros, and Cons
7.3 Total Score

Do you want to taste the most famous US food? Are you curious why so many are dying for a Cheesesteak from Philly, Pizza from NYC, or pie from Texas?

The options are endless, and the good news is that the wait is over. We’ve scoured Goldbelly reviews to show you how you can get your hands on the best the US has to offer.

So let’s explore how the service works and what you can look forward to. 

All About Goldbelly

We review only the best subscription box websites. We’ve compiled lists, reviews, and in-depth analyses on all of them. Now, let’s dive into this Goldbelly review.

Overview and HighlightsGoldbelly ice cream

Joe Ariel started Goldbelly in 2012 with a mission to bring the joy of food to everyone in the US. The service knows how food is bringing us all together and connecting us.

The whole point of Goldbelly delivery is for customers to enjoy fantastically curated products. Also, it helps small businesses, new chefs, and shops to get their products out there.

Goldbelly Is Best For

It’s a fantastic service for foodies who want to enjoy cuisine from across the country in the comfort of their own homes.

Goldbelly Is Not Good For

The service may not be a great choice if you’re not curious about new food. The point is to get you out of your comfort zone and try meals from all over the US.

What Does Goldbelly Offer?

Goldbelly cakeAny Goldbelly monthly subscription review will tell you this isn’t a standard subscription service. It’s an online marketplace put together by local and regional artisanal food purveyors all over the US. 

The Goldbelly team curates products from each establishment and features them on the site. There’s so much on offer — from sandwiches and ice cream to cookies and BBQ. But we’ll tell you all about it shortly. 

You can purchase the items yourself or choose one of the many subscriptions. Also, if you have a foodie friend, this is the ultimate gift.

Before jumping into the best Goldbelly items, note that the service doesn’t make any of the food. It merely curates the items on the site and makes them available to you.

Ice Cream Monthly Subscription

We all know someone who loves ice cream. But with so many flavors, how do we know what to get them? That’s where the ice cream subscription comes in. Your loved one can enjoy either 5–6 pints or 6–24 ice cream sandwiches per month. 

Some examples include:

  • Austin’s Lick Honest Ice Creams
  • San Francisco’s Popular Humphry Slocombe Ice Cream
  • LA’s Amazing Coolhaus Ice Cream Sandwiches

Goldbelly reviews show that all items are hand-picked every month. Still, ice cream isn’t the best snack if you’re on a diet. If you’re looking for a service with healthy snack options, we recommend you check Naturebox’s customer reviews

Monthly BBQ Subscription

BBQ is an obsession of many. And who wouldn’t want to get the best BBQ every month?

Here are a few examples of what the subscription includes:

  • North Carolina’s King’s BBQ Ribs & Pulled Pork
  • Los Angeles’ Revered Bludso’s BBQ Rib Tips
  • Texas’ Hall of Fame Snow’s Ribs & Sausage

Plus, more than one Goldbelly BBQ subscription review mentions that the box is a big enough meal for four people

Monthly Pizza SubscriptionGoldbelly Pizza

Pizza is always a winner, whether it’s a wood-fired, deep dish, thin crust, or coal oven. The subscription is great, and you get hand-picked pizzas each month. The options are endless.

Some box examples include:

  • Brooklyn’s Popular Coal Oven Pizza by the slice from Table 87
  • Detroit’s Pan Pizza from Detroit Style Pizza Company
  • Nebraska’s Unique Rocket Inn Pizza

Goldbelly pizza reviews also mention that each monthly box can feed about four people.

Monthly Bacon Subscription

Bacon can come in many flavors and types. It can be smoked, rubbed in sugar, or even chocolate-dipped. 

Some previous bacon subscription examples include:

  • Nashville’s Iconic Loveless Cafe Southern Bacon Sampler
  • Brooklyn’s Legendary Peter Luger’s Extra Thick Cut Bacon
  • One of the “Best Bacons in America” Bill-E’s Small Batch Bacon

Every box includes 2–5 lb of bacon that can serve around six people. 

Monthly Cookie Subscription

Goldbelly cookiesCookies are a go-to feel-good food, so why not ensure a package of the best for yourself? 

Our Goldbelly cookies review confirms that each month’s hand-selected cookies from across the nation arrive straight at your door.

Here are some previous examples:

  • Los Angeles’ Unique Craftsman & Wolves Cookie Combo
  • Maui’s Maui Cookie Company’s Hawaiian Cookies
  • Minnesota’s Humongous T-Rex Cookie Company GIANT Cookies

You can give yourself or your loved ones the chance to taste the best the US has to offer. Plus, Goldbelly food reviews show each box can serve 6–8 people. 

Monthly Pie Subscription

Pie is an all-American favorite. And with so many options, it can be hard to know which flavor or type to get. But you don’t have to select just one. Goldbelly has a monthly pie subscription that delivers some of the US’s most famous pies. 

Examples include:

  • Texas’ Legendary Royers Pies “Texas Trash Pie”
  • Dangerously Delicious’ “Baltimore Bomb” Pie
  • Wisconsin’s Elegant Farmer “Brown Bag” Apple Pie

Each box is enough for 6–8 people. If you can’t make up your mind, you could go with Goldbelly favorites on a monthly, 3, 6, or 12-month subscription. Also, some subscriptions support specific areas, like Miami and San Francisco. 

How Does Goldbelly Work?

Now that we know what’s on offer, let’s see what to expect from the service. 

Website Experience 

The website is easy to navigate if a bit cluttered for our taste. Also, some of the options are a bit challenging to find, especially the subscriptions. 

But overall, the site is quick and efficient

Ordering ProcessGoldbelly Ice-cream

If you want to sign up, here’s what to do:

  • Go to the Goldbelly website.
  • Click sign up.
  • Enter your email and password.
  • Place your order.
  • Select the subscription frequency.
  • Checkout.
  • Enter shipping and payment details.

The process takes just a few minutes, and it’s super easy. 

Managing Your Subscription

Since Goldbelly delivery deals with perishables, you can’t return items. But if there’s anything wrong with your order, you can contact customer service (, and they’ll try to rectify the situation. 

Once you sign up, you can’t cancel or pause your subscription until the end of the agreed term. That said, you can cancel an order as long as it’s three days before the shipping date. Some Goldbelly negative reviews complain about customers having to contact the company directly to cancel a subscription. 

Goldbelly Pricing, Discounts & Options

There are quite a few pricing options for the monthly subscriptions:

  • BBQ — $99Goldbelly pie
  • Ice Cream — $89
  • Pizza — $89
  • Bacon — $65
  • Cookie — $49
  • Pie — $55
  • Sandwich — $89
  • Cake — $75

Goldbelly bills when you place your order. It varies for each subscription but will show on your profile. Also, you can get $25 off your first order by providing your email address. 

While the price may seem a bit much, if you compare it to the pricing of Goldbelly competitors or the establishment, it’s either the same or only slightly higher.

Shipping & Packaging

Goldbelly packaging consists of ice packs and insulation to keep items cold. The service does all it can to deliver your order in the best possible condition. But some factors are out of the company’s control, like the weather and events preventing transport.

Since some orders travel long distances, you may notice an issue with freshness if anything compromises the process. Goldbelly delivery is available throughout the domestic US. Unfortunately, due to California and Arizona agriculture laws, perishable items may not make it into the states, but you’ll get a refund if this happens. 

Most products offer free shipping. If that’s not the case, the site will calculate it at checkout. 

Saving Opportunities 

Once you have a profile, you’ll receive a referral code. If someone uses it at checkout, you’ll get $25 in credit. 

Customer Service

Goldbelly reviews mention a few ways to contact the service. But before you try that, we recommend checking the FAQ section as it covers a lot of information. If you need specific help, you can:

  • Call: 1-888-675-6892 (9 AM–9 PM EST Monday–Friday and 9 AM–8 PM EST Saturday-Sunday)
  • Chat: Online (9 AM–6 PM EST, Monday–Friday)
  • Email: (8 AM–8 PM EST)

Most customers receive a quick and helpful response:

“Excellent customer service. Great variety. Fast shipping.” — Sarah Summers

Goldbelly Reputation & Customer Satisfaction

Goldbelly cookiesWe’re super impressed by the thousands of Goldbelly delivery reviews online. Most consumers are delighted with the service and praise the food quality, customer service, and delivery. Here’s what they say:

“Great service and quick shipping. I sent a rum cake for a Christmas gift and I was told it was delicious!” — Food Explorer 

While most enjoy the service, some Goldbelly bad reviews point out that the prices are too high:

“Good selection; customer service was able to edit an order; delivery on-time. But prices are exorbitant.” — RR

Despite this, the ratings are excellent, staying around 4.7 stars

Goldbelly Alternatives — How Does It Compare?

There are so many different food subscriptions. So we like to put them up against each other to see how they compare.

Harry and DavidGoldbelly vs Harry and David

These two subscriptions are quite similar in how they work, but they differ in offerings. Harry and David is more of a gift subscription with wine, fresh fruit, and cheese options. In contrast, Goldbelly sends products straight from establishments. 

Price-wise, both vary quite a lot. Goldbelly offers monthly subscriptions ranging between $49 and $99 per month. Meanwhile, Harry and David have monthly subscriptions around  $12.99–$349.99. 

Goldbelly vs Gourmet Food World

Both offer gourmet food delivered straight to your door. But Gourmet Food World isn’t a subscription service. Instead, you select the products you want and pay for them directly. There are many options, including Norwegian salmon, truffles, mushrooms, olive oil, and pastries. With Goldbelly, you can also select and pay for items, but it’s more famous for its subscriptions.

If neither of these tickles your fancy, maybe meal kits you can prepare at home will. If so, we recommend checking the Hello Fresh plans and pricing. 

Stock YardsGoldbelly vs Stock Yards

Stock Yards is a meat delivery service that brings you quality products, including steaks, roasts, seafood, and chops. It offers two subscriptions that cost $199.99–$349.99 per month. 

In contrast, Goldbelly has a BBQ subscription for just $99 a month. That said, you may not find the unique options available at Stock Yards.

Comparison Table



Harry and David

Butcher Box

Stock Yards

Starting Price





Minimum Order



$137 per month


Types of Subscriptions










Delivery Area (N of States) and other countries

The Domestic US


48 Contiguous States

Continental 48 States

Wrap Up — Is Goldbelly Worth It?

Goldbelly offers a pretty unique service, and we think it’s absolutely worth it. We don’t like being confined to food in our area and praise the choices. 

So, if you’re a person who craves specific foods, this is the perfect option for you. Plus, you can order items from different states. A Cheesesteak just isn’t the same unless it’s from Philly.


  • Large variety
  • Great gift ideas
  • Products from all over the US


  • Expensive
  • Delivery services could improve

Bottom Line

Goldbelly is a marketplace that helps businesses sell their products to a wide audience across the US. While it might be pricey, the items are all hand-selected from a massive array of options.


What is Goldbelly?

Goldbelly is a curation service that helps restaurants, chefs, and small businesses to sell their products on an online marketplace. That’s how customers from all over the US can enjoy famous foods. 

How much is Goldbelly shipping? 

Most products include shipping, but the fees for some items are calculated at checkout. You’ll see if that’s included on the product page.

How does Goldbelly work? 

Goldbelly partners with businesses to bring the joy of food across the US. You can either place an order directly or sign up for one of the fantastic monthly subscriptions. For more information, scroll up to check what Goldbelly reviews say.

7.3 Total Score

Products Quality
Originality & Variety
Box Value for Money
Packaging & Delivery
Customer Service
User Rating: 2.6 (10 votes)

Register New Account
Reset Password