If you’re looking for a meal delivery service that will fit your needs, you have two great options: Dinnerly and EveryPlate. Both services offer affordable prices and delicious food but also unique benefits.
In this article, I’ll compare Dinnerly vs EveryPlate in terms of quality, recipes, and price to help you decide which service is right for you. Let’s get started.
Dinnerly vs EveryPlate — What Are They?
Before I compare these two services, it’s good to know how they started and when.
Dinnerly is an affordable meal kit subscription starting at just $4.99 per person. You can select your meal options and a weekly delivery date when you’ll receive the ingredients in an insulated box right at your doorstep.
You can choose from various healthy and quick-prep meal options that are also kid-friendly. After receiving the ingredients, you cook the meal by following the detailed instructions on digital Dinnerly recipe cards.
EveryPlate has a slight difference in pricing, meal portions, and recipes. Its meals start at $4.99 per person, and you can prepare them in 30 minutes or less, following six simple steps.
Every week, you’ll find 14 new options written on convenient EveryPlate recipe cards that are helpful and easy to follow.
If you want to learn more about Dinnerly and EveryPlate, keep reading.
Who Owns Them?
The well-known chef Martha Stewart co-owns Dinnerly, together with the meal kit delivery giant Martha & Marley Spoon.
Dinnerly was founded in 2017. Today, it’s among the most popular and affordable meal delivery services on the market. It’s reached the point where the Dinnerly competitors include Home Chef, HelloFresh, and Blue Apron.
In contrast, EveryPlate was founded in 2018 with the simple idea of providing everyone with delicious and affordable home-cooked meals. The company started as a low-cost version of HelloFresh which stands as a big name in the meal kit industry.
EveryPlate vs Dinnerly: What Do They Offer?
After an in-depth review of EveryPlate, I concluded that this meal kit company offers a unique approach to home-cooked meals. Rather than fully prepared meals, the service sends you a box of ingredients and a step-by-step recipe card.
EveryPlate makes cooking fun and interactive experience, perfect for families or those who enjoy spending time in the kitchen.
Dinnerly also offers various delicious and hearty meals, perfect for the budget-conscious family. Just like EveryPlate, the company sends you fresh and carefully picked ingredients for your next meal.
With Dinnerly, you can choose from a wide range of recipes, all designed as quick and easy to prepare. Also, Dinnerly offers a flexible subscription that lets you customize your order to suit your needs.
Let’s dive in and see which one is better, Dinnerly vs Everyplate?
Is the Food Good?
If you’re a fan of home-cooked meals and delicious American classics, you’ll love both services and their recipes. But Dinnerly vs EveryPlate reviews show that one company is slightly better in meal portions, ingredient freshness, and taste. Which one is it? Read on to find out.
Let’s first explore each service’s most famous recipes.
- Burger With Zesty Potatoes
- Cashew Chicken Stir With Rice Noodles
- One-Pot Pizza Tortelloni
- Dinner-Style Chicken and Gravy
- Panko Ranch Pork Chops
- Dijon Butter Steak
These recipes are mouth-watering! They’re so good that you might want to subscribe to both meal kit plans.
Dinnerly claims that its ingredients come from a reliable source. The company lists all ingredients for each meal, with special caution for allergens.
Most fruits and vegetables in Dinnerly meal kits are conventional, which may not be ideal for organic diets. Still, no one should expect organic and premium cuts for such a low price. Keep in mind that you’ll need some additional items like oil, salt, and pepper because you won’t find any in a Dinnerly meal kit.
The decision between choosing Dinnely or EveryPlate can be a tough choice since these are very similar meal kit subscriptions.
Like Dinnerly, EveryPlate offers fresh ingredients that are always protected from heat and contamination. The company states that everything in the box is made and raised in the US. But don’t expect organic and non-GMO products for the price you pay.
When Dinnerly is compared to EveryPlate in terms of ingredient freshness, the former takes better caution regarding use-by dates. EveryPlate’s ingredients will stay fresh up to 48 hours after delivery. The company guarantees that you can cook and eat everything without worrying about the quality in the next seven days.
Dinnerly is more rigorous regarding customer safety. The service strongly suggests you should consume seafood dishes within the next two days after receiving them. Also, you must cook chicken and ground meat meals in 3–4 days. Lastly, meat and vegetable recipes should stay fresh for five days.
Dinnerly vs EveryPlate portions are specifically designed to save you time in shopping and cooking. The recipes are quick and easy to make.
Dinnerly provides instructions on digital recipe cards you’ll receive after you log into your account. Unlike EveryPlate’s printed cards, Dinnerly brings the meal kit service to the next level by digitalizing it.
Both kits provide clear instructions for anyone — from inexperienced chefs to aspiring Gordon Ramsays. A Dinnerly meal usually consists of five steps or less, while EveryPlate has six.
Note that these meal kit services won’t teach you cooking techniques. Before you subscribe, you need to know the basics; otherwise, even the easiest recipe will be complicated to make.
Comparing EveryPlate vs Dinnerly in the meal prep category, I definitely prefer Dinnerly because of its no prep kits. You get simple recipes without having to chop or cook anything. It doesn’t get easier than this.
Variety Of Meals
The EveryPlate vs Dinnerly portion size and meal variety is a tight battle. Both stick to the traditional American cuisine without experimenting with lots of ingredients and spices.
The winner in portion sizes is Dinnerly, as it’s consistent and generous with every recipe. Also, it offers 18 menu options, compared to EveryPlate’s 11 recipes.
You can even find a few vegetarian options on every Dinnerly menu or subscribe to the veggie plan. Also, the meal variety includes categories like:
- Under 30 minutes
- One-pot meal
- No gluten
- Healthy meals
So, is Dinnerly healthy for a meal kit subscription? Generally, it is. The options accommodate almost every taste and need. Plus, you can choose between ready-made desserts and additional protein-rich items.
In contrast, EveryPlate’s menu doesn’t offer much customization. You’ll see some vegetarian meals, but you can’t subscribe to a full vegetarian plan.
Both Dinnerly and EveryPlate favor meat and side recipes, with a sauce or dressing to spice things up. So, expect to see many similar recipes with sides of pasta, potatoes, rice, peas, or beans and a bunch of healthy veggies. You’ll find such ingredients on either menu almost every week, with few exceptions around the holidays.
Generally, the services offer balanced and tasty meals. Considering the EveryPlate and Dinnerly pricing, that’s a fair deal, especially for large families.
Both companies include diet labels and allergen information during meal selection. The difference is that Dinnerly has a keto option, as well as dairy and gluten-free recipes and low-calorie meals.
In contrast, the only specific diets on EveryPlate labels are vegetarian and spicy. Also, there’s a small range of options if you want to add proteins or veggies to your meal at a higher price.
Although EveryPlate doesn’t offer keto meals or low-calorie recipes, people are very satisfied with its organized allergen list that you can find after every recipe.
To sum up, having dietary restrictions will make your meal kit decision harder, but if I have to choose, I’d go with Dinnerly.
What Are the Meal Plans and Prices?
Dinnerly and EveryPlate have similar basic meal prices, starting at $4,99 per serving.
But is Dinnerly or EveryPlate a better option for the family budget? Let’s find out by breaking down their meal plans along with the price.
EveryPlate weekly plans with two servings:
- 3 meals — $45.33
- 4 meals — $53.91
- 5 meals — $62.89
EveryPlate four-person weekly plans:
- 3 meals — $69.87
- 4 meals — $89.83
- 5 meals — $109.79
Dinnerly weekly two-person plans + shipping:
- 3 meals — $48.33
- 4 meals — $57.91
- 5 meals — $68.89
- 6 meals — $79.47
Dinnerly four-person family plans
- 3 meals — $78.27
- 4 meals — $97.83
- 5 meals — $115.79
- 6 meals — $129.75
Shipping is the same for both services, and it costs $9.99. I’ve included it in the final prices above.
So, is Dinnerly or EveryPlate cheaper? It depends on how many meals you want. Generally, the more you order, the more you save, but EveryPlate is somewhat cheaper.
How Do Delivery and Packaging Work?
Meal delivery services like EveryPlate and Dinnerly work the same. They send you meals once per week, with enough ingredients to prepare everything you’ve ordered. The most significant difference is that EveryPlate lets you select a delivery date between Tuesday and Friday.
When it comes to packaging, both companies use recyclable plastic and reusable ice packs to keep the food fresh up to 48 hours from the delivery day.
Can You Modify Your Orders or Cancel?
Dinnerly and EveryPlate have many alternative solutions for their hungry fans. You can cancel online or modify your subscription up until the week before your next delivery. Also, both offer a money-back guarantee if you aren’t satisfied with your order. But Dinnerly’s cancellation policy is more flexible than EveryPlate’s.
You can cancel your Dinnerly subscription at any time without penalty. In contrast, EveryPlate requires you to cancel at least five days before your next delivery to avoid being charged for the next month.
Is Their Customer Service Good?
Both services offer phone support and an email form. That said, EveryPlate’s customer service number is more available, starting on Monday to Friday from 6 AM to 11 PM ET. Also, you can find the 24/7 live chat on EveryPlate’s website. While Dinnerly also has a phone number, its working schedule is unclear — 888-267-2850.
Live chat has many advantages over the traditional phone support, which is why EveryPlate is an absolute winner for better customer support and availability.
Are Customers Satisfied?
Looking back at the Dinnerly and EveryPlate pricing, recipes, and ingredients, I expected to find many positive reviews.
Here’s what Pat, a satisfied EveryPlate subscriber, wrote:
“Thank you! Everyone at EveryPlate has been great — the customer service, prompt communications, great recipes, and life-made-simple-in-a-box! My son is a full-time college student, and also works full-time in a “big-boy” job; takes care of his own house about 5 hours away. He’s only 22, but he’s been cooking for himself for a couple of years. EveryPlate makes life so much easier for him, and so much happier for me, knowing that he’s got fresh food to cook during this incredibly busy time in life!”
Here’s why Jack, a Dinnerly customer, says the service is worth it:
“The price and quality are so great and worth it and honestly, I don’t know why more people don’t use them cuz I would forever be using them. The recipes are extremely good and not that difficult for me; I can prepare them easily being a person who had never cooked before, to follow. We also have an option of choosing from healthy, vegetarian, family-friendly, and fast meals.“
People love Dinnerly and EveryPlate’s recipes, and they enjoy cooking them too.
What Are Their Competitors?
Every meal kit subscription tries to meet its customers’ needs. Let’s see how some of the leading companies in the food delivery market differ and why.
Dinnerly vs EveryPlate vs HelloFresh
Dinnerly, EveryPlate, and HelloFresh are all meal subscriptions worth considering. They offer affordable meal kits with fresh, high-quality ingredients.
Unlike Dinnerly and EveryPlate, HelloFresh uses mostly organic ingredients and has more meal varieties. Also, HelloFresh offers low-calorie meals and vegan and pescatarian options that are in huge demand.
On HelloFresh’s menu, you can find more than 25 recipes every week. But if you want to stick to traditional, hearty dishes, opt for Dinnerly or EveryPlate.
Dinnerly vs EveryPlate vs Blue Apron
Starting from $7,99 per meal, Blue Apron is the priciest option of all three, but it also offers the most variety and the best quality ingredients.
While Dinnerly and EveryPlate try to make things easier for their customers, Blue Apron likes to challenge people by offering more advanced recipes.
Another bonus point for Blue Apron is its free shipping for orders over $50. In contrast, I appreciate the more affordable options with Dinnerly and EveryPlate. They’re the first and only choice for some elderly people, students, and working mums.
To sum up, many other meal delivery services can be better or worse than Dinnerly or EveryPlate. At the end of the day, it’s all about your personal needs and preferences.
If you want more options, look into Amazon Fresh, Doordash, Veestro, and Green Chef.
Dinnerly Pros and Cons
EveryPlate Pros and Cons
After putting Dinnerly vs EveryPlate side to side, it’s time to announce a winner. Both have a lot to offer, so it all comes down to what you’re looking for in a meal kit.
If you’re looking for the most affordable option, Dinnerly is the way to go. But if you want spicier meals, Everyplate might be a better fit. Whichever you choose, you’ll be getting fresh ingredients and delicious meals.
Dinnerly had me at garlic butter chicken and fries, so it’s definitely my top pick!